Dean's Office Official Model Question Paper

Cooperative Enterprise and Democratic Control

A cooperative enterprise is an autonomous association of persons united voluntarily to meet their common economic, social, and cultural needs and aspirations through a jointly-owned and democratically controlled enterprise.

One Member, One Vote: Regardless of the number of shares owned by an individual member, each member possesses exactly one equal vote in general assembly governance, ensuring democratic equality and preventing capital oligarchies.

The 7 ICA Cooperative Principles

1. Voluntary and Open Membership.
2. Democratic Member Control.
3. Member Economic Participation.
4. Autonomy and Independence.
5. Education, Training, and Information.
6. Cooperation among Cooperatives.
7. Concern for Community.

PEARLS Monitoring System

PEARLS is a standardized quantitative financial performance monitoring tool developed by the World Council of Credit Unions (WOCCU) evaluating SACCOs across six areas:

• P: Protection (loan loss provisions)
• E: Effective financial structure
• A: Asset quality
• R: Rates of return and costs
• L: Liquidity
• S: Signs of growth

Functions of Cooperative Act 2074

The Act modernizes cooperative governance by establishing regulatory ceilings on savings mobilization, mandatory reserve fund allocations (25% to General Reserve), limits on promoter lending, cross-district operations rules, and establishing the Cooperative Department and Credit Information Bureau.

Primary Society vs. Cooperative Federation

• Primary Cooperative Society: Formed at the grassroots level by individual natural citizens (minimum 30 members) to provide direct mutual services (e.g., local dairy or saving cooperative).
• Cooperative Federation: A secondary or apex union formed by primary cooperatives to provide advocacy, bulk purchasing, training, and liquidity clearing across member societies.

Structural Governance Crisis in Nepalese SACCOs

Savings and credit cooperatives in Nepal have faced severe systemic liquidity runs and depositor bankruptcies.

1. Core Structural Drivers of Crisis

• Regulatory Fragmentation & Jurisdictional Confusion: Under federalism, regulatory oversight of cooperatives was split between federal, provincial, and local municipal levels without institutional inspection capabilities, creating regulatory arbitrage.
• Promoter Capture and Insider Embezzlement: Rogue executive boards and chairpersons diverted public savings into personal real estate, luxury automobiles, and unhedged shell companies without board collateral.
• Aggressive Unregulated Growth: SACCOs operated as shadow commercial banks, mobilizing billions in deposits through high interest rates (14%–16%) without maintaining mandatory liquid statutory reserves.
• Mismatch in Asset-Liability Maturities: Using short-term, callable member deposits to fund illiquid, speculative long-term real estate plots.

2. Liquidity Runs and Contagion

• When real estate asset prices stagnated, borrowers defaulted, and promoters could not liquidate land.
• Panicked depositors rushed to withdraw savings simultaneously; lacking central bank lender-of-last-resort support or deposit insurance, dozens of prominent urban cooperatives collapsed.

Cooperative Governance Architecture

Cooperative governance relies on institutional checks and balances between policy, execution, and oversight.

1. General Assembly (Supreme Democratic Body)

• Composed of all voting cooperative members on a ‘One Member, One Vote’ basis.
• Approves annual policies, audited balance sheets, surplus distribution, by-law amendments, and elects the Board and Audit Committee.

2. Board of Directors (Executive Policy Body)

• Elected by the General Assembly (typically 7 to 11 members).
• Formulates operational policies, sets interest rates, evaluates loan proposals within statutory limits, and supervises the Chief Executive Officer.

3. Audit Committee (Lekha Samiti - Independent Oversight)

• Directly elected by the General Assembly, independent of the Board of Directors.
• Conducts quarterly internal financial audits, monitors loan disbursement compliance, verifies cash and security balances, and reports financial irregularities directly to the General Assembly.

Financial Prudential Norms for Cooperatives in Nepal

The Department of Cooperatives enforces mandatory financial prudential standards:

1. Capital Adequacy and Reserve Funds

• Institutional Capital: Cooperatives must maintain institutional capital (retained reserves) of at least 8% to 10% of total assets.
• Mandatory Reserve Allocations: Cooperatives must transfer at least 25% of annual net operating surplus to the General Reserve Fund, and 10% to Cooperative Education and Community Funds before declaring dividends.

2. Statutory Liquidity Maintenance

• Must maintain at least 10% to 15% of total member deposits in liquid assets (cash in vault, call deposits in commercial banks, and treasury bills).

3. Loan Loss Provisioning Norms

• Good Loans (0 to 30 days overdue): 1% general provision
• Substandard Loans (30 to 90 days overdue): 5% provision
• Doubtful Loans (90 to 365 days overdue): 35% provision
• Bad / Loss Loans (> 365 days overdue): 100% full provisioning

Agricultural and Multipurpose Cooperatives in Rural Transformation

Agricultural cooperatives serve as vital social capital for rural farming communities in Nepal.

1. Collective Bargaining and Economies of Scale

• Bulk Input Procurement: Purchasing subsidized fertilizers, high-yield seeds, and solar drip irrigation systems in bulk, bypassing exploitative middleman markups.
• Market Power: Aggregating smallholder milk, vegetables, ginger, and cardamom to negotiate bulk selling contracts with urban supermarkets and export aggregators.

2. Value-Addition and Supply Chain Infrastructure

• Establishing community-owned milk chilling centers, automated tea processing factories, and cold storage facilities in rural districts (e.g., Ilam, Dhading, Chitwan).
• Enabling smallholder farmers to capture value-added margins previously appropriated by intermediaries.

Case Analysis: Turnaround of Himalayan Samriddhi SACCO

a. Statutory Breaches and PEARLS Violations

1. Promoter Insider Lending & Single Obligor Breach: Section 50 of the Cooperative Act strictly caps individual member loans at a maximum percentage of capital fund and bans insider lending to board relatives. Disbursing 66% of total credit to the chairman’s family entities is criminal fraud.
2. Catastrophic Liquidity Deficit (PEARLS ‘L’ Failure): Liquid reserves of 1.5% violated the statutory 10% minimum threshold, causing instant operational collapse upon withdrawal stress.
3. Fictitious Profit Accounting & Fraudulent Dividends: Distributing 18% dividends while harboring 55% unprovisioned bad loans violates capital preservation rules and criminalizes the board under fraudulent accounting statutes.
4. Collapse of Audit Committee Governance: Compromising the Lekha Samiti dismantled the primary internal check mandated by the General Assembly.

---

b. Crisis Liquidity Management and Phased Repayment Plan

1. Tiered / Phased Withdrawal Moratorium:
   • Tier 1 (Small Depositors < Rs 50,000): 100% immediate repayment, resolving panic for 60% of member households with minimal capital drain.
   • Tier 2 (Mid-Level Depositors Rs 50,000 to Rs 500,000): Phased monthly disbursements of 10% over 10 months.
   • Tier 3 (Large Institutional/High-Net-Worth Depositors > Rs 500,000): Voluntary debt-to-equity conversion into preferred cooperative shares with guaranteed dividend yields upon recovery.
2. Emergency Liquidity Consortium: Secure a temporary revolving liquidity line from the National Cooperative Bank Ltd. (NCBL) secured by clean performing loan portfolios.

---

c. Legal Enforcement, Asset Tracing, and Criminal Prosecution

1. Immediate Board Dissolution & Problematic Cooperative Declaration: The Ministry/Department of Cooperatives declares the entity a ‘Problematic Cooperative’ under Section 104, suspending all board powers and appointing a statutory Administrator.
2. Asset Freezing & Exit Control: Central Investigation Bureau (CIB) freezes all domestic bank accounts, shares, and land parcels registered in the names of the chairman, directors, and their relatives, placing them on the national exit control list.
3. Foreclosure on Real Estate Collateral: Auction the confiscated real estate properties developed with embezzled cooperative funds to channel proceeds directly into depositor repayment accounts.

---

d. Institutional Restructuring and Transparent Governance

1. Democratic Re-Election of Independent Board: Convene a supervised Special General Assembly to elect an uncompromised board excluding real estate promoters.
2. Real-Time Member Financial Portal: Launch a secure digital banking portal where members can view real-time monthly PEARLS prudential ratios, liquidity reserves, and certified audit reports.